The Palm Beach Post

Treasure Coast homeowners say banks illegally locked them out

October 22nd, 2010 by TCPalm.com

By George Andreassi

Bank operatives changed the locks at Jillian Winterberg’s Vero Beach house twice this year even though the property has not yet gone through the mortgage foreclosure process.

Even worse, Winterberg said, after the first break-in she found her personal documents had been rifled through, putting her at risk of identity theft and financial ruin.

“Someone had opened the trunk where I keep my old financial documents, all of my old tax returns, payment info. It was spread all around,” said Winterberg, a banking industry employee. “I still just cannot get over it. This is something I’m probably going to have to monitor for the rest of my life.”

In response, Winterberg filed a lawsuit charging Wells Fargo Bank, the Federal National Mortgage Association (Fannie Mae) and First American Real Estate Information Services with breach of contract, trespass, invasion of privacy and intentional infliction of severe emotional distress.

Representatives of Wells Fargo Bank, Fannie Mae and First American Real Estate Information Services, which is now known as CoreLogic, said they would discuss the case with corporate legal officials, but generally do not comment on litigation.

Some banks appear to have over stepped legal boundaries by prematurely taking control of homes whose owners are behind on their mortgage payments, said Winterberg’s lawyer, Kevin Rollin of Vero Beach, and several other Treasure Coast lawyers involved in foreclosure defense.

“The practice being employed by some banks in Florida to simply lock out property owners without obtaining a court order or the owners expressed consent is simply unlawful,” Rollin said. “Florida courts have held it to be trespass where a mortgagee changes the locks on a property in advance of obtaining title pursuant to a foreclosure sale — even if the mortgagee mistakenly believed they could do so.”

Trent Steele, a Hobe Sound lawyer whose practice includes foreclosure defenses, said he has several clients who fell behind on their mortgage payments and had the locks changed on their homes by bank operatives without a court order.

However, the banks and their maintenance companies claim they’re entitled to secure the properties whose mortgages are in default to make sure the assets are not damaged, Steele said.

“I’ve had many clients call me in a panic and say, ‘I tried to get into my house tonight and the locks were all changed,’ which is something I think shouldn’t be going on,” Steele said.

“They go in and they change the locks and turn the power off and do all kinds of other things to supposedly protect the property,” Steele said. “The problem is that in many cases my clients are taking perfectly good care of the property. There is no evidence that they’re not maintaining it.”

Ramsey Harris, a disabled veteran who had been renting a house in Rocky Point that went into foreclosure, said he believes JP Morgan Chase moved way too fast when the bank hired a company to move his belongings into the street during a rain storm.

One of the movers was arrested for allegedly pocketing some of Harris’ valuables, a sheriff’s report says.

“I think it was cold,” Harris said about the eviction. “They destroyed everything that I had worked for. All of my valuables were ransacked and gone through. I had devastating losses, stuff that I can’t replace.”

Most of his clothing, furniture and decorations were ruined by the rain or hauled off by scavengers, Harris said. He’s been staying at a neighbor’s guest house since the eviction, while trying to find an apartment.

A West Palm Beach law firm has agreed to represent him for free, Harris said.

Daisy Cabrera, a spokeswoman for JP Morgan Chase in Florida, declined to comment on how Harris was treated by the law firm that handled the eviction proceedings in Martin County Circuit Court, or the company that moved his belongings into the street.

“The whole thing from start to finish was wrong because the paperwork (of the bank’s lawyers) filed at the courthouse was wrong,” Harris said. “They knew I was there. They didn’t notify me at all. They acted as if I was a non-person.

“It happened to me and it still seems like it was a bad dream,” Harris said. “I want somebody to slap me upside the head and wake me up because it doesn’t seem like it was real.”

TREASURE COAST FORECLOSURES

Martin County

2005: 127

2006: 253

2007: 797

2008: 1,742

2009: 2,082

2010

January: 158

February: 180

March: 128

April: 126

May: 101

June: 121

July: 129

August: 140

September: 122

Total: 1,205

St. Lucie County

2005: 485

2006: 1,327

2007: 4,873

2008: 9,570

2009: 8,324

2010

January: 507

February: 646

March: 442

April: 465

May: 333

June: 338

July: 420

August: 429

September: 471

Total: 4,051

Indian River County

2005: 183

2006: 335

2007: 1,086

2008: 2,493

2009: 2,471

2010

January: 190

February: 215

March: 159

April: 163

May: 132

June: 159

July: 157

August: 169

September: 163

Total: 1,507

Posted October 21, 2010 at 7:54 a.m., updated October 21, 2010 at 11:40 a.m.

9 Responses to “Treasure Coast homeowners say banks illegally locked them out”

  1. Half Pint Says:

    ALL homeowners (those that are paying and those who are unable to pay) should request the recorded document that reflects that the “mortgage co.” is entitled to the payments- generally called an “Assignment of Mortgage”- request it by certified letter to insure they receive the request. If you don’t get it in 30 days- do it again (make a copy an hand write “2nd request”, take your mortgage payments and place them in a escrow bank account at a bank. You do not need permission to do this from the court, you are legally entitled to the document that proves the bank is entitled to your payment. When they finally decide to either send you your legally entitled document- then release the payments. Until then, wait until they file documents in court and have all of your certified letters to show the judge. If the bank is stupid enough, as the article reflects, to change the locks- you change them after they do.

    If all homeowners did what was stated above- the banks would have no laternative than to sit down and deal fairly with you. If they don’t, take that huge nest egg and leave the house -on your terms.

  2. larry Says:

    Gold diggers just trying to hit the lottery go get a real job and pay your bills and these things wouldn’t happen. Don’t sue just look in the mirror and ask yourself did you work as hard as you could have to pay your bills. Move on quit looking for handouts!!!!

  3. steve Says:

    “Larry says”= is a MORON. With no job, and no hope of finding one in a State such as Florida has, in fact we are the 3rd highest State regarding overall unemployment. Its simply impossible to “get a real job” as Larry states. This sanctimonious fool is just that- a fool, or a long time government paid employee, with no learned abilities to “have any other real job”

  4. American Patriot Says:

    HERE IS THE PROOF OF MASSIVE FRAUD AND WHY THE FBI WILL NOT STOP IT and neither will the Government. OUTRIGHT FRAUD.

    Foreclose on the Foreclosure Fraudsters, Part 1: Put Bank of America in Receivership

    After a quick review of its procedures, Bank of America this week announced that it will resume its foreclosures in 23 lucky states next Monday. While the evidence is overwhelming that the entire foreclosure process is riddled with fraud, President Obama refuses to support a national moratorium. Indeed, his spokesmen on the issue told reporters three key things. As the Los Angeles Times reported:

    A government review of botched foreclosure paperwork so far has found that the problems do not pose a “systemic” threat to the financial system, a top Obama administration official said Wednesday.

    Yes, that’s right. HUD reviewed the “paperwork” problem to see whether it threatened the banks — not the homeowners who were the victims of foreclosure fraud. But it got worse, for the second point was how the government would respond to the epidemic of foreclosure fraud.

    The Justice Department is leading an investigation of possible crimes involving mortgage fraud.
    That language was carefully chosen to sound reassuring. But the fact is that despite our pleas the FBI has continued its “partnership” with the Mortgage Bankers Association (MBA). The MBA is the trade association of the “perps.” It created a facially ridiculous definition of “mortgage fraud.” Under that definition the lenders — who led the mortgage frauds — are the victims. The FBI still parrots this long discredited “definition.” That is one of the primary reasons why — in complete contrast to prior financial crises — the Justice Department has not convicted a single senior officer of the large nonprime lenders who directed, committed, and profited enormously from the frauds.

    Note that the Justice Department is not investigating foreclosure fraud. HUD Secretary Donovan’s statement shows why:

    “We will not tolerate business as usual in the mortgage market,” he said. “Where there have been mistakes made or errors, we will hold those entities, those institutions, accountable to stop those processes, review them and fix them as quickly as possible.”
    Note the language: “mistakes”, “errors”, “processes” (following the initial use of “paperwork”). No mention of “fraud”, “felony”, “criminal investigations”, or “prosecutions” for the tens of thousands of felonies that representatives of the entities foreclosing on homes have admitted that they committed. Note that Donovan does not even demand that the felons remedy the harm caused by their past fraudulent foreclosures. Donovan wants them to “fix” “processes” — not repair the harm their frauds caused to their victims.

    The fraudulent CEOs looted with impunity, were left in power, and were granted their fondest wish when Congress, at the behest of the Chamber of Commerce, Chairman Bernanke, and the bankers’ trade associations, successfully extorted the professional Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) to turn the accounting rules into a farce. The FASB’s new rules allowed the banks (and the Fed, which has taken over a trillion dollars in toxic mortgages as wholly inadequate collateral) to refuse to recognize hundreds of billions of dollars of losses. This accounting scam produces enormous fictional “income” and “capital” at the banks. The fictional income produces real bonuses to the CEOs that make them even wealthier. The fictional bank capital allows the regulators to evade their statutory duties under the Prompt Corrective Action (PCA) law to close the insolvent and failing banks.

    The inflated asset values allow the Fed and the administration to ignore the Fed’s massive loss exposure and allow Treasury to spread propaganda claiming that TARP resolved all the problems — at virtually no cost. Donovan claims that we have held the elite frauds accountable — but we have done the opposite. We have made the CEOs of the largest financial firms — typically already among the 500 wealthiest Americans — even wealthier. We have rewarded fraud, incompetence, and venality by our most powerful elites.

    If the government does not hold the fraudulent CEOs responsible, who is supposed to stop the epidemic of elite financial fraud? The Obama administration’s answer is the fraudulent CEOs themselves, at a time of their choosing. You can’t make this stuff up.

    But ultimately resolving the problems is not the government’s responsibility, said Michael Barr, assistant Treasury secretary for financial institutions.

    “Fundamentally, this is up to the banks and the servicers to fix,” he said. “They can fix it as fast as they feel like.”

    So who is Michael Barr and why is saying things on behalf of the Obama administration that make it appear to be a wholly-owned subsidiary of the fraudulent lenders and servicers? He’s a Robert Rubin protégé and he’s the senior Treasury official for banking policy.

    We have a different policy view. We believe that only the government can stop fraud from growing to catastrophic levels and that among the government’s highest responsibilities is to provide the regulatory “cops on the beat” with the competence, resources, courage, and integrity to take on our most elite frauds. We believe that anything less is a travesty that causes tens of millions of Americans to be defrauded and poses a grave threat to our economy and democracy.

    Prompt Corrective Action

    First, it is time to stop the foreclosures until the banks and servicers adopt corrective steps, certified as adequate by FDIC, that will prevent all future foreclosure fraud. They must also adopt plans to remedy the injuries their foreclosure frauds have already caused, and assist the FBI, Department of Justice, and legal ethics officials investigations of their officers’ and attorneys’ frauds and ethical violations.

    Second, it is time to place the financial institutions that committed widespread fraud in receivership. We should remove the senior leadership of the banks and replace them with experienced bankers with a reputation for integrity and competence, i.e., the honest officers that quit or were fired because they refused to engage in fraud. We should prioritize the receiverships to deal with the worst known “control frauds” among the “systemically dangerous institutions” (SDIs). The SDIs’ frauds and fraudulent leaders endanger the global economy.

    We propose Bank of America for the first receivership. In the last few weeks, the SEC has obtained a large (albeit grossly inadequate) settlement of its civil fraud charges against the former senior leaders of Countrywide. (Bank of America acquired Countrywide and is responsible for its frauds.) Fannie and Freddie’s investigations — with their findings reviewed by their regulator, the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) — have identified many billions of dollars of fraudulent loans originated by Countrywide that were sold fraudulently to Fannie and Freddie through false representations and warranties. The Fed, BlackRock, and Pimco’s investigations have identified many billions of dollars of fraudulent loans provided by Countrywide under false reps and warranties. Ambac’s investigation found that 97% of the Countrywide loans reviewed by Ambac were had false reps and warranties. Countrywide also engaged in widespread foreclosure fraud. This is not surprising, for every aspect of Countrywide’s nonprime mortgage operations that has been examined by a truly independent body has found widespread fraud — in loan origination, loan sales, appraisals, and foreclosures. Fraud begets fraud. Lenders that are control frauds create criminogenic environments that produce “echo” epidemics of control fraud in other professions and industries.

    We have been amazed that, as one financially sophisticated entity after another found widespread fraud by Countrywide in the entire gamut of its operations, the administration, the industry, and the financial media act as if this is acceptable. Countrywide made hundreds of thousands of fraudulent loans. It fraudulently sold hundreds of thousands of loans through false reps and warranties. It fraudulently foreclosed on large numbers of loans. It victimized hundreds of thousands of people and hundreds of financial institutions, causing hundreds of billions of dollars of losses. It has defrauded more people, at a greater cost, than any entity in history.

    Bank of America chose to purchase Countrywide at a point when it — and its senior leaders — were infamous. Bank of America made some of these Countrywide leaders its senior leaders. Yet, Bank of America is not treated as a criminal entity. President Obama, Attorney General Eric Holder, Donovan, and Barr cannot even bring themselves to use the “f” word — fraud. They substitute euphemisms designed to trivialize elite criminality. The administration officials do not call for Bank of America to be the subject of a criminal investigation. They do not demand that Fannie, Freddie, Ambac, the FHFA, and Pimco file criminal referrals about Countrywide’s frauds. They do not demand that Fannie, Freddie, and the Fed refuse to purchase or take as collateral any mortgage instrument from Bank of America. No one at the Harvard Club in New York moves to kick Bank of America’s officers out of their club! The financial media treats Bank of America as if it were a legitimate bank rather than a “vector” spreading the mortgage fraud epidemic throughout much of the Western world.

    For the sake of our (and the global) economy, our democracy, and our souls this willingness to allow elite control frauds to loot with impunity must end immediately. The control frauds must be taken down and their officers removed promptly. Receivership is the way to begin to reclaim our souls, our economy, and our democracy and Bank of America has the track record that makes it a good place to start. It is sufficiently large and powerful that its receivership will send the credible signal that America is restoring the rule of law and that even the most elite frauds will be held accountable.

    Next we need to remove the rest of the “too big to fail” institutions — we call them systemically dangerous institutions, or SDIs — to reduce the global systemic risks that they pose. We are rolling the dice with disaster every day. The SDIs are inefficient, so shrinking them will reduce risk and increase efficiency. We need to follow three types of policies with respect to SDIs.

    1.They cannot grow larger and compound the systemic risk they pose.
    2.They must create an enforceable plan to shrink to a level and functions such that they no longer pose a systemic risk within five years.
    3.Until they shrink to the point that they no longer pose systemic risks they must be regulated with far greater intensity than other banks. In particular, control fraud poses so severe a risk of triggering another global financial crisis that there must be no regulatory tolerance for control frauds at the SDIs. One of the best ways to reduce their risks is to mandate that high levels of executive compensation be paid only after sustained and superior performance (at least five years), and with “claw back” provisions if compensation was obtained by fraudulent reported income or seriously inadequate loss reserves.
    Appointing a receiver for an SDI will be a major undertaking for the FDIC, but it is also well within its capabilities. Contrary to the scare mongering about “nationalizing” banks, receivers are used to returning failed banks to private ownership. Receiverships are managed by experienced bankers with records of competence and integrity rather than the dread “bureaucrats.” We appointed roughly a thousand receivers during the S&L and banking crises of the 1980s and early 1990s under Presidents Reagan and Bush.

    Here is how it works. A receiver is appointed on Friday. The bank opens for business as normal (from the bank’s customers’ perspective) on Monday. The checks clear, the ATMs work, and the branches all open. The receiver’s managers direct the business operations, find the true facts about the bank’s operations, senior managers, and financial condition, recognize the real losses, and make the appropriate referrals to the FBI and the SEC so that the frauds can be investigated and prosecuted.

    The receiver is also a well-proven device for splitting up banks that are too large and incoherent by selling units of the business to different bidders who most value the operations.

  5. Deadbeat Central Says:

    Throw the deadbeats out…ASAP…all they want is 2 years with no payments

  6. Half Pint Says:

    American patriot: I commend you on your intelligent and informative post.

    Let the ones slinging the word “deadbeat” pray that karma isn’t listening. The are more people out in the country that are unemployed, due to no fault of their own, the benefits have stopeed and there are still no job prospects.

    ALL OF US, working or not, deliquent or not- need to request this important document that names the mortgage holder that is entitled to their monthly mortgage payments.

    Until the banking institutions start to realize that, we the consumer, are the ones that are in control- they will continue to act in the fraudulant manner to which they have accustomed their business practices to without fear of reprisal from the government.

    IF we all consumers started to invoke our federal legal right to have this document in our possession- the banks would have no alternative than to respect their customers and treat them accordingly.

  7. Tweets that mention Treasure Coast homeowners say banks illegally locked them out | Treasure Coast Talk -- Topsy.com Says:

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Palm Beach Post, Treasure Coast Talk. Treasure Coast Talk said: Treasure Coast homeowners say banks illegally locked them out http://bit.ly/bZplJp [...]

  8. American Patriot Says:

    Thank you half pint

    People need to realize the Big Banks are fleecing anyone and everyone they can.

    Most of you probably had your credit card rates raised without notice.

    I hope you are all watching Greece and france because even Time Magizine is predicting massive Civil Unrest and the possibility of civil war in the U.S.

    Please look up the Trends research Institute. They have been 100% accurate for thirty years in forecasting what is coming.

    Things are going to get really bad here.

    My Family and relatives have all been storing Food. Medical Supplies and Water and something to defend ourselves with.

    I hope you all out there are preparing.

  9. JayP Beats Says:

    JayP Beats…

    [...]Treasure Coast homeowners say banks illegally locked them out | Treasure Coast Talk[...]…

Leave a Reply

We'd like your thoughts on this story. I appreciate your willingness to share them. At PalmBeachPost.com, we want to avoid comments that are obscene, hateful, racist or otherwise inappropriate. If you post offensive comments, we will delete them as soon as we can. If you see such comments, please report them to us by clicking this link.

Tim Burke, Publisher, The Palm Beach Post.

News, weather, sports on PalmBeachPost.com
Video from the treasure coast

Want to chat about the Treasure Coast? Want to rant or rave? Visit our Community Post chat room, formerly Backyard Chatter.

Do you have photos you’ve taken that you want to share with other readers? If so, send them here and we’ll publish them online and in The Palm Beach Post’s Neighborhood Post section on Thursdays. Be sure to include who shot the photo, where it was shot, where you live and the names of everyone in the photo. Let’s see your photo skills! Photos Browse the photo galleries here.

Treasure Coast police blotters Keep track of crime in your area with Neighborhood Post's weekly roundup of arrests.


Your home for youth sports news in Palm Beach County and the Treasure Coast. Read the blog and share your comments.
Archives